Picking a dog collar might seem simple, but there’s more to it than grabbing the first one off the shelf. The right collar isn’t just about looks. It plays a big role in your dog’s comfort, safety, and even behaviour.

Whether you’re welcoming a new puppy or upgrading your current gear, choosing the right collar matters. So, what should you actually look for?

Why the Right Collar Makes a Difference

A good collar from the likes of Fetching Ware does more than just hold your dog’s ID tag. It helps with training, keeps your dog from bolting into traffic, and gives you control when you need it.

The wrong collar? That can mean chafing, slipping out, pulling too hard, or your dog straight up refusing to wear it. It can also make training harder than it needs to be.

The goal is something that works for your dog, not just for you.

Start With Your Dog’s Size and Breed

Not every collar suits every dog. What works for a chunky bulldog won’t work for a tiny Chihuahua.

A few things to think about:

• Neck size – Measure your dog’s neck snugly but not tightly. Then add about 2 fingers’ worth of space. That’s your ideal fit.
• Weight – Heavier dogs may need stronger, more durable collars to avoid breakage or wear.
• Fur type – Long-haired breeds may do better with flat collars to avoid matting, while short-haired dogs may tolerate more styles.
• Head shape – Some breeds with narrow heads (like greyhounds) can slip out of regular collars. They often need something designed with that in mind.

You’ll also want to think about how much your dog pulls on the lead, their energy level, and how well they respond to commands. All of that influences the kind of collar that will actually work for them.

Understanding Collar Types

Now let’s get into styles. Each one serves a different purpose, and what works for one dog might be a nightmare for another.

Flat collars are the most common. They’re simple, easy to use, and work well for most dogs who are already leash-trained. They’re also ideal for holding ID tags.

Martingale collars are designed for dogs who slip out of regular collars. They gently tighten when your dog pulls, but won’t choke. Popular with breeds like whippets or greyhounds, or for dogs still learning to walk nicely on a lead.

Harnesses are a completely different option, but worth mentioning. They’re ideal if your dog pulls or has breathing issues, since they take the pressure off the neck entirely. Not technically a collar, but some owners swap between the two depending on the situation.

Head collars are sometimes used for training, especially with big, strong dogs. They give more directional control by guiding the head, but they can take time for a dog to get used to.

Material Choices (And Why They Matter)

It’s not just about how a collar looks; it’s about how it feels on your dog’s skin, how long it lasts, and how easy it is to maintain.

Nylon is lightweight, easy to clean, and affordable. It’s great for everyday use, but may wear out quicker if your dog is rough on the gear.

Leather takes longer to break in, but is usually more comfortable and long-lasting. Some dogs with sensitive skin do better with leather, though it needs a bit more care.

Biothane is a newer option that’s waterproof, stink-proof, and strong. If your dog swims or rolls in everything, this could be a solid choice.

If your dog has had reactions to collars before, it’s worth testing out different materials and watching for signs of irritation.

Getting the Fit Right

Too tight, and it can cause discomfort or even restrict breathing. Too loose, and it’s a slipping hazard. A good fit means it sits flat around the neck and doesn’t shift much during movement.

Watch how your dog acts when it’s on. Scratching, fussing, or freezing in place can mean something’s wrong, whether that’s the size, the weight, or the feeling of the material.

Make sure the buckle’s secure, especially if your dog is on the stronger side. And if your dog’s still growing, look for a collar with enough adjustment range to last a few months.

When It’s Time for a New One

Collars wear out, some quicker than others. It’s easy to miss the signs, especially if it still looks fine at a glance.

Here’s when it’s time to upgrade:

• Fraying or tearing – Even minor damage can lead to breakage
• Stretching – If the collar no longer holds its shape, it’s less secure
• Faded or brittle material – Sun and moisture can weaken fabric over time
• Rusty or loose hardware – Buckles and D-rings must stay solid
• Behavioural changes – If your dog suddenly resists the collar, it might be uncomfortable

Check it regularly—every few months is a good habit. A five-second check can prevent a serious issue down the line.

Do You Need Special Features?

Some collars come with reflective strips, quick-release buckles, built-in ID panels, or waterproof coatings. These extras can be handy depending on your lifestyle.

Night walker? Reflective stitching helps with visibility. Got a dog that loves the ocean or mud? Waterproof materials save a lot of cleanup.

Just don’t get caught up in features for the sake of it. Focus on what will genuinely help you and your dog day-to-day.

Don’t Skip the ID Tag

This one’s easy to overlook, especially if your dog’s microchipped. But if your dog gets loose, a visible ID tag with your contact info is the fastest way to get them back to you.

Make sure the tag is legible and up to date. If your dog wears a collar most of the time, it’s worth investing in one with a quiet tag attachment or built-in ID plate so it doesn’t jingle or catch on things.

Wrapping It Up: What Actually Matters

A good dog collar doesn’t need to be fancy. It just needs to work. Look for one that fits well, suits your dog’s body and behaviour, and feels good for them to wear. Skip the trends and base your decision on what your dog actually needs.

In the end, the right collar is about freedom and safety for both of you. And once you find the perfect one, walks get easier, training feels smoother, and your dog just feels… happier.